A new Oratorio

DM 6th April 2024

I’ve booked tickets to see Mendelssohn’s oratorio Elijah next month, and so am trying hard to get the music into my head, in order to heighten the appreciation of the live performance, and to not expose my ignorance. But it’s a struggle. It’s not as sweet as Handel’s Messiah, and the airs and recitatives and choruses feel somewhat clunky and discordant. Maybe it’s Mendelssohn. Maybe I’m just a pleb.

Apparently when Mendelssohn was scratching around for an idea after the success of his first composition St Paul, a friend suggested an ‘Elijah’, a ‘St Peter’, or even an ‘Og of Bashan’. The first suggestion was taken up, the second never got started, and the third was surely made tongue-in-cheek. Og is hardly one of the significant characters of the Bible, and the Biblical information amounts to this: He was a giant who ruled over sixty cities, slept in an extra-king-size bed, and opposed Moses in his advance to the Promised Land.

One wonders what any composer would do with that. Perhaps a jeering duet: ‘Og made his bed for the last time.’ Then a bold quartet: ‘God is not afraid of giants.’ Followed by a booming chorus: ‘The bigger they are, the harder they fall.’ Then maybe a sweet air: ‘God looks upon the heart, and sees not as man sees.’ And the grand finale: ‘The Lord is my helper; I will not be afraid. What can mere mortals do to me?’ There’s the libretto. Composers, over to you.

Recent Posts

Correcting bias 

Correcting bias DM 17th July 2026 I think my wife needs a wheel alignment. When we go for a walk around the block, I’ve found that I have to walk

Read More »

Yeah, Nah

Yeah, Nah DM 10th July 2026 ‘Yeah, Nah’ has just been promoted to OED status, which ought to impress most Aussies and Kiwis who are

Read More »

The Other Elam

The Other Elam DM 3rd July 2026 If David Beckham was in my school year, I would be known as ‘the other David’. Likewise if

Read More »

Red cards

Red cards DM 26th June 2026 “That was a foul! Surely ref! Come on! Are you blind?! Send him off! Red card! At least a

Read More »

An Iliad

An Iliad DM 19th June 2026 “Rage! Goddess, sing the rage of Peleus’ son Achilles / that destructive wrath which brought countless woes upon the

Read More »

One blood

One blood DM 5th June 2026 In 1830, Robert FitzRoy captained the Beagle that carried Charles Darwin on his famous voyage. Darwin wrote his account.

Read More »

Man flu

Man flu DM 29th May 2026 Man-flu is a real phenomenon, and I have just proved it by careful scientific experiment. My wife and I

Read More »